Thursday, August 20, 2009

I Hate The War

Last Thursday, we were noting Zachary Abrahamson and Eamon Javers' "Barack Obama's words downplay wars" (Politico) which detailed how Barack rarley brought up the Iraq War when speaking to the press (or Afghanistan, but our focus is Iraq). And we noted that Abrahamson and Javers did a wonderful thing by documenting that; however, there was another side to explore: the press.

The press doesn't ask about Iraq. And yesterday Baghdad was rocked by a series of bombs and the death toll is over 100 and the injured number over 560. The Foreign Ministry and the Finance Ministry were targeted in what is being seen as an attack on the central government itself. No one knows who is responsible. At first the central government -- the Shi'ite dominated and controlled central government --tried to blame a polyblend of al Qaeda in Iraq and former Ba'athists. However, no one really bought that because al Qaeda in Iraq is a fundmentalist entity and the Ba'athist were a secular political party.

But the security forces had to issue an apology for the massive failure. And Nouri al-Maliki has asked the US military for help with technical aspects (such as forensics).

And violence continued with 17 deaths reported today (71 reported injured).

And outlets such as Bloomberg News, McClatchy Newspapers and ABC News raised issues of what does this mean in terms of the US remaining in Iraq? And a US Lt Gen asked about it said that would be up to the governments of the US and Iraq.

And though they couldn't have known in this afternoon, turns out the 71 wounded? Actually 216 injured. And that 17 dead? 40 dead.

The snapshot included: "Sami al-Jumaili, Michael Christie and Richard Williams (Reuters) report Babel bombings and possible mortar attacks which claimed 7 lives and left fifty-five people injured based on police reports and they note 'there appeared to have been at least three blasts'." Those numbers have risen. Sahar Issa and Adam Ashton (McClatchy Newspapers) report the death toll is 30 and the wounded over two-hundred.

So violence claimed over 100 lives yesterday and at least 40 today.

And you might think Iraq would be on the minds of the press. You'd think wrong.

Click here for the White House press briefing and click here for the State Dept press briefing.

At the White House, Robert Gibbs and the press wasted everyone's time on ObamaInsuranceCare. (Remember to add in the "insurance" now that the White House has made clear that it's "health insurance reform" and not "health care reform.") You really have to watch and see what little whores the press is. They will lie and they will lie again. They will pretend that there is some amazing plan when there's no plan and the details of the meetings that took place at the White House (the few details known) indicate what most always knew, Barack's killing health care. Barack is the death panel. Every 15 years or so, like a political comet, there's a chance for real reform. But it needs to be steered and it needs to be clear what it is and it needs to benefit the people. Barack skipped all three steps. Because the White House was never serious about helping the people.

This is nothing but a big money give-away to Big Pharma and the insurance company.

And the press whores itself out because it will enrich Big Business. Please, GE's going to get on board with something that helps the people and limits Big Business? No. So the MSNBC monkeys whore it out night after night. And Bob Somberby (at The Daily Howler) talks about how the network isn't run by anyone with news experience but equally true is MSNBC sold the Iraq War. MSNBC tried to outFox 'Fox' News. This is the network that hired Michael Savage. There has been no change. Some of the faces changed but it's the same network with the same executives. They're whoring just like they did with right-wing faces. They're whoring and they're lying to you.

If they wanted real conversations about health care, as Stan pointed out last night, they wouldn't invite a comic on. If they wanted real conversations about the issues, they wouldn't invite Janeane Garofalo on. To be clear, Janeane spoke out against the illegal war and that was brave. That was also six years ago and she hasn't done a damn thing since. I meant politically but it's true of her failed career as well. She was going to be a poker player, remember? A sitcom? Don't protest ABC!! Don't do it! She's got another sitcom offer!

Reality, if people had protested ABC for dumping her planned sitcom, she was afraid she'd lose the one where she was a poker player. So she lied to you then and she was willing to lie for her career and what did it get her. She finally got a role on a show that promotes torture (24), one she used to call out and make fun of Rush Limbaugh for (he's friends with the producers). But she's so desperate for anything resembling a career that she grabs a minor role on that show. She's not second banana. That's the actress who plays Chloe. She's not third-string, that's characters like Renee. She's bottom of the barrel, she's last of the speaking roles. Her career is over.

And other than the Iraq War, what is she known for politically? Health care? Janeane's discussing health care? Janeane who fell in with the wackjobs of Scientology and, when called on it, said it was no different than being Jewish?

One's likened to a cult (Scientology, for many, many reasons) and the other's a recognized religion. And the Jewish faith does not believe space ships came down to earth after the space war. Now Scientology isn't a minor thing, she was promoting -- on air -- their 'health care' plans. For fire workers traumatized by 9-11.

And that idiot's going to be brought on MSNBC to talk about health care? That fool? That faded and failed actress?


MSNBC is insulting you everytime they book guests like Bill Maher and Janeane Garofalo. They're clowning and they're doing it because you don't matter to them, Big Business does.

Early on when Janeane -- who never calls out the Iraq War today -- was still semi-functioning in public, she interviewed an actress. She asked a valid question (it was about the 9-11 Truth movement -- Janeane's publicly sympathetic to it, privately she's a follower of it and too damn bad if she didn't mean for that to get out). And the actress sputtered and gasped for air and immediately began insisting that just the question was an insult. The actress was also a member of the 9-11 Truth Movement which is why Janeane asked her the question in the first place. But that actress had seen her career suffer for politics. For years. And it was a slow and difficult climb back. One that few others made. And the actress wasn't about to even play the "Okay, let's be devil's advocate on this, even though I don't believe . . ." Why? She wasn't going to risk politics once again harming her career.

That matters because? Bill Maher doesn't challenge. Bill Maher goes as far his leash allows him to. The same with Janeane. Which is why the two of them appear on MSNBC as 'experts.' When they're not experts on anything. But they know to stay within the lines because they tested the bounds once and it wasn't pretty.

Maher's show was cancelled by ABC and Janeane's career was completely in the toilet. Maher's got HBO, Janeane hopes she has a future somewhere.

They're like the actress Janeane interviewed when she first started on Air America Radio. After the interview, Janeane was trashing the woman and talking about how ridiculous it was that she couldn't even admit that she was a 9-11 Truther. (Which is why I don't feel bad exposing Janeane as one.) She ripped her apart and blah, blah, blah. She'd never be like that. She spoke out against the Iraq War and it hurt her and she would never ever stop being brave and outspoken!

Wrong.

Like that actress, Janeane doesn't have the guts. Bill Maher doesn't either. They risked something once, they won't do it again. Their type never does. They're so damn thrilled there's a semi-respectable club they can belong to that they will never risk anything again. You can watch and you will see it. Bill Maher will be offensive when the topic is women -- as he always has been. But he won't really challenge a White House ever again. Not unless they're tanking in the polls, not a real challenge. Not a 'hey, you're calling people cowards but the reality is it does take bravery to fly a plane into a building.' (And Bill was right there. I don't care for him, I don't like him. But what he said was true -- if you believe planes flew into the Twin Towers and the Pentagon and I do -- and it was brave of Bill Maher because the White House and the press were spinning as something completely different.) They will do the acceptable means of leftness and that's all they'll do. Janeane is a 9-11 Truther. Do you get what that means?

I'm not making fun of her for that. I have friends who believe 9-11 was staged. My opinion has always been, "I don't know, I wasn't there." And when I speak about Iraq there often is someone who wants to bring up 9-11. I'm not hostile to them and I have never had a problem with them. I think the ones who always whine about 'those people' are the ones who take attitudes with the people who showed up for the discussion, with people who wanted to weigh in with their own thoughts and not just sit there passively and nod and applaud. There have been many wonderful exchanges in the last years with 9-11 Truth Movement people. They're not crazy, they're not insane, they're not stupid. They believe something I don't happen to believe but I could be (and often am) wrong. They have their hypothesis of what happened and I have mine. Mine is, as noted here many times, when information is not forthcoming freely, people will create a narrative based on things they believe in and things they have learned. That's what humans do. We are story-tellers. And "story-teller" isn't an insult. Some of the stories we tell are true. But it our natural instinct to take any incident and turn it into a story. All the more so when information is kept from us and information was kept from us regarding 9-11. That shouldn't be debatable to anyone who followed and is able to be honest. My own opinion is that the government doesn't want to be shown to be even more incompentent than they appeared so that's why the clampdown took place. My opinion, I could be wrong. I'm not saying I am right and I'm not insulting the Truth Movement.

But if you're part of the Truth Movement you believe that someone (who depends upon what section of the movement you belong to) engineered 9-11 to start the Afghanistan War. (And depending upon what section of the movement you belong to, that's either your end point or the starting point where you see other things being connected to that.)

Do you not get the point?

Janeane's 9-11 Truth. She can lie and claim she believes Barack's ending the Iraq War. (She knows better.) But Afghanistan? No, there's no way to deny that Barack's beefing up the Afghanistan War, based on his own statements. And not a peep from Janeane. No sitting down with Bill O'Reilly to rage the way she would in 2003 over the Iraq War. No nothing. Not a peep.
And the reason is because she nearly lost it all and she's not going to risk what little she has and come out against the Afghanistan War and hit the arm chair circuit to demand that it end.

Now her career's over. She doesn't seem to grasp that, but it's over. And when she finally does grasp it, she make a move towards honesty. But she's not a talented actress, she plays the same persona (don't call it a character) over and over. She's aging in an industry that doesn't reward maturity in a woman. She's covered herself with freakish tattoos that require make up or clothing to cover in the few roles she could actually land (small roles, character roles). She might suddenly grasp all of that and decide to speak out. But right now, the ruler came down hard on her and as long as she thinks that the big role is just a few months away, she's not risking it.

And that's why she's invited on MSNBC. She will launch into one of her hateful tirades that tells you the entire problem is the Republicans. The entire problem with the country today is . . . the party that does not occupy the White House, the party that does not control the House, the party that does not control the Senate. That party with no power in Congress (the Dems, if they stick together, can ram through anything) is the problem right now.

It's nothing but lies but she feeds you those easy lies and that's why MSNBC loves to have her on. It's not because she's funny. She's not funny. Even when she's not launching a hateful tirade, she's not funny. She's lost her sense of timing (too bad because a one-woman show would be a smart move for her). So much so, that she's not even aware of it -- just like she's not aware that she no longer has the breath to make it to the end of her run-on, random association sentences.

She's not funny, she's not an expert, so why is she on? Because she knows the lines she's allowed to dance in and won't step out of the box. She did once. It was scary. She won't do it again, not while she still thinks there's a chance at fame.

And, let's be honest, riches. You really have to either not give a ___ about money or be independently wealthy (what DG calls your "___ you money") to speak your mind. Janeane's neither nor is Bill Maher. So they come on and do their trained seal act. And everyone pretends that you were informed.

Janeane rants that everyone who disagrees with her is a racist. And somehow you're not supposed to notice that the segment failed to tell you what was in any of the House proposals or the Senate or what the White House has said it wants.

They are a distraction and you need to grasp that the 'health care' coverage has been nothing but a distraction. You need to grasp that you're being lied to over over. Well, the left and the center need to grasp that. The right wing has sensed, rightly so, that there is an attempt to put something over on them. The same Cult of St. Barack that told you that one of the reasons they couldn't support Hillary was because they didn't want a replay of the "Clinton Wars" are encouraging you to replay them.

Bill Clinton wasn't a monster. He wasn't inept. Neither was or is Hillary. (Bill's in private life now so we'll stick with "was" for him.) The attacks on Bill were about discrediting him and removing his power. About boxing him in. And Bob Somerby focuses on the right wing and wonders why the mainstream didn't call it out. But Bob knows why, he's written about it before. It's because they wanted the summer home or some other status symbol or just to be in the club. So they danced for their corporate masters.

The press did not change. It does not change, if the press is famous for anything, it is famous for its own inertia. That's why Robert Novak can get only a mixed report card and why he could remain respectable for so many years. They never clean house unless publicly forced to and then they try to minimize the house cleaning (which is how Judith Miller gets fired but Michael Gordon remains at the New York Times).

So the question should have always been, "Why does the press love Barack?" That wasn't asked in 2008. In 2009, people should be aware enough to ask, "Why does the press keep selling Barack's 'plan' for health insurance reform?"

It's not popular. Less than half of Americans support it.

And he's fallen in the polls.

Normally, when that happens, the knives come out. Now the press is going to sharpen their knives shortly on Obama. But right now, they need to sell that give-away of the public money to Big Business. So right now they don't challenge Barack the way they would another president with the same poll numbers. Right now, they continue giving him a pass.

You need to grasp what's happening because the big money give-away to insurance companies isn't the only thing Barack campaigned on when he surrounded himself with his DLC peers. (Barack was DLC, Glenn Ford and Bruce Dixon admit it and admit that they sugar coated their article for The Black Commentator.) What sent shudders repeatedly during the campaign? What had the Cult of St. Barack saying, "He doesn't realize . . ." NO, he realizes. Social Security.

You better grasp that the press' efforts to sell ObamaInsuranceCare is the trial run for selling the privatization of Social Security. Barack's not just the fresh face of empire, he's the fresh face of all George W. Bush couldn't accomplish. The mainstream pimped him over and over. Why? Because their masters holding the leash told them to. You're seeing the same thing with ObamaInsuranceCare and, if it passes the Congress, prepare to see a similar press response when it's time to privatize Social Security.

I was not planning on saying that much. Two things. 1) When ObamaInsuranceCare passes or fails, at Third, I will be suggesting and advocating for a serious discussion of the issue of health care. We didn't have it and what MSNBC and the others offered was damn embarrassing. I am for single-payer, I am for Medicare For All. But I'm also for the truth and I don't think you trick the people to sell your plan. I think you need to be honest with them about what a single-payer plan would mean and there's been damn little honesty on Barack's minuscule "public option" plan. Second, I'm told Politico often has audio to their stories. I'll try to check that out. I don't care for Politico but if audio is a regular option to at least some of their text stories, we will put them on the permalinks because we serve all members of the community and that does include some of our oldest community members who are couples where one of them has poor eye sight or no eye sight. That's why we include audio links and note that there is an audio option. We started doing that a long time ago and I'm glad it's become popular at sites that are not part of this community. I have no idea why they ran with it but the reason we started it -- yes, we did start it -- was because of a diverse community. And "we started it" is not a brag for me. Community members pushed it. Community members raised the issue of how one of them reads the entry here to the other and then the interesting link or two is something that gets checked out and sometimes the one reading has to get some water because of all the reading out loud. Community members made it clear that in their situation, a link that had audio meant they could enjoy listening together. If Politico includes audio for just some stories, my own personal distaste for it doesn't matter, it'll be on the permalinks to the left. Bob Somerby's mentioned twice (at least twice) in this. I don't have time to find it (I've still got to do three columns tonight for the community newsletters), so click here for The Daily Howler.

It's over, I'm done writing songs about love
There's a war going on
So I'm holding my gun with a strap and a glove
And I'm writing a song about war
And it goes
Na na na na na na na
I hate the war
Na na na na na na na
I hate the war
Na na na na na na na
I hate the war
Oh oh oh oh

-- "I Hate The War" (written by Greg Goldberg, on The Ballet's Mattachine!)


Last Thursday, ICCC's number of US troops killed in Iraq since the start of the illegal war was 4331. Tonight? 4332.

The e-mail address for this site is common_ills@yahoo.com.







Iraq snapshot

Thursday, August 20, 2009. Chaos and violence continue, yesterday's Baghdad bombings had a death toll of 95 and that toll has risen, surprisingly little broadcast media coverage of the violence, 11 Iraqi security forces are arrested, Cindy Sheehan gears up for demonstrating on Martha's Vineyard and more.

Sinan Saleheddin (AP) notes yesterday's Baghdad bombings resulted in the deaths of "at least 101 people and wounded more than 500." A death toll like that -- even half that -- would generally result in some reporting on your TV screens. That wasn't the case. Commercial broadcast networks? NBC Nightly News with Brian Williams, of all the commercial network evening news shows, stood alone in offering a report on the bombings.

Lester Holt: This is one of the bloodiest days in a long time in Iraq. It's certainly the most violent since US forces withdrew from Iraqi cities in June. Multiple bombings killed at least 95 people in Baghdad and wounded more than 500. A major test for Iraq's security forces and for US policy. We get more now from our Pentagon correspondent Jim Miklaszewski. Mick, good evening.

Jim Miklaszewski: Good evening, Lester. US officials are already blaming al Qaeda for today's bombings in an effort to stir up sectarian violence but whos ever responsible, today's bloody and blatant bombings raise serious questions about Iraq's ability to take over its own defense. Six powerful bombs rocked Baghdad within minutes in one of the deadliest days of the entire Iraq War. One blast shook up a meeting of tribal leaders. As smoke filled the room, the speaker called it terrorism. The carnage began with a suicide car bombing at Iraq's Finance Ministry at about eleven this morning. Only three minutes later, a massive truck bomb exploded outside the Foreign Ministry. Then over the next ten minutes four separate bombs tore through Baghdad in a highly coordinated attack. The Foreign Ministry took the most devastating hit -- two tons of explosives shredded the front of the building, killing at least 59 Iraqis. The wounded flocked to Baghdad hospitals. This man said one explosion threw his car into the air. The attacks come less than two months after American combat forces withdrew from Baghdad in an agreement with Iraq's government. Iraqi forces were supposed to take over security operations, but after today's bombings, NBC News producer Ghazi Balkiz says the Iraqis admit they failed in their mission.

Ghazi Balkiz: In a surprising statement tonight, the Iraqi Defense Ministry admitted that the attacks were the result of Iraqi forces negligence and said that they should take most of the blame for the security breach.

Jim Miklaszewski: Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki could ask the US forces to return to the cities but that would be political suicide and it's unlikely American combat forces would step back into the middle of an Iraqi sectarian war.

Ret General Barry McCaffrey : The last time we went in to take Baghdad, we had several thousand killed and wounded. We won't do it again. We shouldn't do it again.

Jim Miklaszewski: And despite today's attacks and a recent spike in overall violence, US military and Pentagon officials say they still intend to withdraw all US combat forces on schedule. According to one senior official, it's time for the Iraqis to step up and take over ready or not. Lester.

Lester Holt: Jim Miklaszewski, tonight at the Pentagon, thank you.

One of the deadliest days of the entire Iraq War and instead of covering that, CBS Evening News with Katie Couric spent nine minutes on the passing of CBS News' Don Hewitt. 'Once upon' a noted passing at a network resulted in the final thirty seconds with a title card showing the date of birth and date of death. Last night, CBS short changed the news and wallowed in an attempt to turn a private tragedy into world news. On non-commercial broadcast TV, PBS, The NewsHour spoke with Jane Arraf (Christian Science Monitor) about the bombings in Baghdad (link has text, audio and video option).

RAY SUAREZ: Jane Arraf, welcome to the program. You were in the part of Baghdad targeted by these attacks. Tell us what you saw.

JANE ARRAF: Well, it was mostly what I heard, first of all. I was going to the U.N., which was commemorating the sixth anniversary of the bombing of U.N. headquarters, when there was a huge explosion, which turned out to be a mortar, landing fairly close to the U.N. building. And then the blast, this huge blast that was part of a wave of explosions that rocked Baghdad in what really is the biggest security challenge, perhaps, to the Iraqi government in some time, and certainly a challenge to Iraqi security forces' ability to secure the city. Now, the biggest one was outside the Foreign Ministry, where a truck packed with an estimated ton of explosives detonated. There was another bomb shortly after near the Finance Ministry that collapsed part of an overpass. Now, these are some of the most heavily defended buildings in Baghdad. Iraqi authorities say that they confiscated a third truck packed with explosives and showed that on television, big, red plastic barrels filled with explosive material. All in all, it's seen as a test, and a test that Iraqi security forces have failed today.

RAY SUAREZ: Who is the Iraqi government blaming for this explosion? Who would have an interest in committing this kind of crime?

JANE ARRAF: Well, that's the problem in Iraq. Pretty much everyone has an interest, but this specifically, the Iraqi government is saying it's Sunni insurgents and former Saddam loyalists, a strange sort of mix. But it does have the hallmarks of al-Qaida. I went to the site later this afternoon to see what the wreckage looked like and talked to some of the survivors, and it was a huge bomb that actually did look quite a bit like -- the remnants did look like that bombing six years ago.
It was a truck that managed to get close enough and packed with enough explosives that it did tremendous damage. The big ones are normally thought to be al-Qaida, the big suicide bombs, sophisticated attacks, coordinated attacks, and that's who's being blamed for this one today, being blamed, as well, on the streets. A lot of Iraqis think this is either al-Qaida or ex-Baathists, although some of them persist in believing it's the Americans.

If the US just had two broadcast networks, it would have been a pretty good night for US news thanks to NBC and PBS. CBS tossed online Sheila MacVicar's report features CBS News' Mohammed Khalil stating, "Just like the days of the war. You could see dead people in cars still burning. Very awful." At one minute and 23 seconds, more time was spent on 'memories' of Don Hewitt than on reporting deadly violence. On 'memories'. That's not counting the lengthy opening report. That' just trotting out Andy Rooney and others to offer their thoughts on Don's passing. Anyone with half a brain knows you do not make the death of one of your own behind the camera people -- natural causes death -- the LEAD story on your evening broadcast. Anyone with half a brain knows that in 22 minutes newscast, you do not spend 9 minutes on the death of one of your own. 1 minute and 23 seconds is how long Sheila MacVicar's report is. They couldn't spare more time because they devoted 9 minutes to Don Hewitt and, please note, the first person to scream the loudest over that would have been Don Hewitt.

***ADDED: The above has been altered at a friend (at CBS's request). A friend at CBS News states Sheila MacVicar's report did air on the East and Central time zone's CBS Evening News. If so, one minute and 23 seconds were spent on Iraq and over nine minutes on Don. Almost everyone I know is on vacation so I'm going by one person and only one person stating the report aired. It is not on the Evening News I Tivo-ed. I don't do corrections in snapshots, the policy is the next day. I'm doing this because "I'm swearing to you, we had that report" is what I was told. Normally, I would want more than one person stating that. It also doesn't explain why one person at CBS gave me the time Sheila MacVicar's report was dumped online but I can't get ahold of him right now. Because "I'm swearing," I'll take the word of one and change the above. **********

101 deaths and over 570 injured from violence versus the natural causes death of one name not known outside the news industry? Which was news? If you picked "B," you're an embarrassment and may have a bright future in TV news -- at least on CBS and ABC.

Ernesto Londono and Greg Jaffe (Washington Post) report a despondent, 54-year-old man sat outside the Foreign Ministry, eyeing, wondering about his two sons whom he couldn't be reach by phone and who "worked at the ministry," his two sons of whom he says, "They've disappeared." That is a story. That is news. News is Adam Ashton (McClatchy Newspaper) quoting Um Khatab asking, "Where are the police? I lost a brother, and they are sitting in their cars with air conditioning?" News is Adam Ashton informing, "Her cries of mourning reverberated in the street while teams of police officers sifted through the site, making their way past burnt-out cars and scorched pavement." Jane Arraf (Global Post) reports, "After the active nightmare of the bombing, by evening the street had the feel of a bad dream -- amid the groups of curious young men, a ministry employee wlaked with blood seeping through the bandage on his head. An anguished mother stumbling over her shoes asked everyoen if they'd seen her missing daughter." It shouldn't be difficult to grasp the heartache and loss of over 100 unexpected deaths due to violence. It shouldn't be but apparently at the once upon a time Tiffany network, it is.

But, hey, CBS News just ignored the tragedy. The White House celebrated it. Jake Tapper and Karen Travers (ABC News) report "A Senior Administration official" states "we believe these attacks will energize our Iraqi partners" and Tapper and Travers underline that comment by observing, "Note the spin at the end that this will energize iraqi troops, not scare them off -- not a view held by all observers of the conflict." Apparently the White House believes, when over 100 people die in bombings, squeeze their bones and call it lemonaide? At the White House today, spokesperson Robert Gibbs did not denounce the remarks thereby saying to the world, "That unnamed official was speaking on behalf of the White House." (For potential fall out effects from the remark, click here.)

The New Statesman observes, "The bombs, which went off yesterday, were directed against the main centres of power, including the parliament and cabinet buildings and the ministries of finance, foreign affairs, health, housing, and education." Robert Dreyfuss (The Nation via NPR) uses the bombings as an attempt to grind his axe against the Kurds, "While President Obama and the Pentagon are focused on Afghanistan, the war in Iraq is showing signs of heading south, and fast. It's not unexpected. Iraq's Arabs and Kurds are nearly at war along the long front that separates the Kurdish region from the rest of Iraq, especially in and around Nineveh province, whose capital is Mosul, and over Tamim province, whose capital, Kirkuk, is coveted by the expansionist Kurds." It takes a real hatred to find a way to attack the Kurds in the midst of supposedly addressing the Baghdad bombings. As Dreyfuss damn well knows, Kirkuk is disputed and Saddam Hussein was the one who kicked the Kurds out of the region. Kirkuk is coveted by the expansionist Nouri al-Maliki and the central government of Baghdad as much as it's covered by "the expansionsit Kurds". It's that kind of observing that reminds people Dreyfuss used to work for Lyndon LaRouche. The Guardian points to: "The cocky reaction of Iraqi generals and police chiefs when the Americans began their withdrawal to the sidelines looks pretty overblown in retrospect. Not only could they handle security as well as the Americans, some of these officers implied, they could handle it better with the foreigners out of the way. Now the Iraqi forces are face to face with their own deficiencies." Liz Sly and Usama Redha (Los Angeles Times) add, "U.S. helicopters were seen buzzing over the blast sites Wednesday, but Maliki did not ask for help." The Financial Times of London counters that violence would always happen (true) and that the problems are the security forces ("little more than rebadged militia") and "Although Nouri al-Maliki, the Shia Islamist prime minister, is trying to reinvent himself as a nationalist, he has failed to pursue the national reconciliation -- above all with a Sunni minority dispossessed of power by the invasion -- for which the 'surge' was meant to create space. Instead, ahead of elections in January, he has vaingloriously taken credit for reduced violence and for the US troop pullback he hails as a 'liberation'." Jane Arraf (Christian Science Monitor) reports, "Prime Minister Nouri al-Malaki and senior officials met late into the night after the attacks to reassess security measures. The government had pledged to remove concrete blast walls from the city's main roads and reopen streets closed to traffic by mid-September, but now residents expect them to stay." Sahar Issa and Adam Ashton (McClatchy Newspapers) report, "Eleven Iraqi police and military officers are under arrest as part of an investigation into how two trucks loaded with explosives managed to detonate outside government offices Wednesday . . . The detained officials include two army regiment commanders, the commander of a police emergency company and five chiefs of neighborhood police units."

Kirit Radi (ABC News) reports on the Pentagon press conference US Lt Gen Frank Helmick participated in today via videolink from Baghdad where he declared, "What I am personally frustrated with is that, again, we must continue to develop the capabilities inside the Iraqi military. And we are doing that as fast as we can. My frustration is we -- I am not doing it fast enough." Viola Gienger (Bloomberg News) adds that the Lt Gen revealed Nouri's people were asking for US "intelligence, surveillance and forensics assistance". She notes that when Nouri was in DC last month, he floated the idea that US troops might remain in Iraq past the end of 2011.
The US military presence on the ground in Iraq needs authorization. Any foreign military being on the ground in Iraq needs authorization. The failure of the British and Iraqi government to reach an agreement (Parliament adjourned before finalizing the agreement) is why the British military had to pull back to Kuwait last month. For the bulk of the illegal war, the invasion was illegal but the occupation had the cover of the United Nations. The UN did not authorize the invasion. It did authorize the occupation and that provided the authority for foreign forces to be on the ground in Iraq. Nouri wasn't supposed to renew the mandate in 2006 but he did. And he did so without the authorization of the Parliament. That's an important detail. Parliament was outraged. He vowed he would get their approval next time but as the mandate was set to expire, he renewed it in 2007. Without their approval. For a vareity of reasons -- including Iraq's debt issues -- Nouri did not want to renew the mandate when it expired December 31, 2008. He and the White House went with a treaty masquerading as a Status Of Forces Agreement. The SOFA replaces the UN mandate. Each year the UN mandate had to be renewed. To bide time, the SOFA allowed US forces to remain in Iraq for three years. (The contract can be cancelled by either side at any time. 12 months after official notification of cancellation, all US forces would have to be out of Iraq.) The SOFA did not end the Iraq War. That is a misreading of the SOFA and of contract law. The SOFA replaces the UN mandate and, instead of being yearly, covers three years. If it's not renewed or if it's cancelled -- and if nothing replaces it -- US forces have to leave. But the SOFA is not "THE END OF THE IRAQ WAR." If it was that, then all hail George W. Bush for ending the Iraq War because the SOFA is George's document. Barack's chosen to follow it but it's George's document.

Nouri is correct that the US could stay on if the prime minister of Iraq and (maybe) their Parliament wanted it. "Maybe" on the Parliament -- as counseled by the US State Dept in 2006 and 2007, Nouri knows his cutting the Parliament out of the UN mandate issue allowed him to seize powers which the prime minister can now maintain is his or her power due to "custom." That has implication in terms of the elections scheduled for January which Nouri is currently stating will include a referendum on the SOFA. By "custom," the vote matters less than the prime minister's say so. The Parliament grumbled in 2006 and 2007 but did not seek to address the issue (renewing the UN mandate) through the court system or pass binding legislation. By "custom," Nouri's established the renewal option as belonging to the office of the prime minister. So Nouri may let the SOFA go to a vote but that vote would only matter if the prime minister (which may or may not be Nouri) decides it matters. That's for January.

In terms of US forces leaving Iraq, the SOFA does not mean that. The SOFA was not created to end the Iraq War. It was created to replace the UN mandate (Nouri didn't want to renew it due to the economic issues among other things; the Bush administration didn't want to renew it due to the obligations the US would have as an occupying power -- obligations never lived up to and that had received very little attention). The SOFA was about finding a way for US forces to remain in Iraq. If it runs the full three years, it can expire at the end of the three years and the US military (except marines guarding the US embassy in Baghdad) could leave. But it can also be renewed or replaced with another agreement. The SOFA does not say: "THERE SHALL BE NO RENEWAL." It's a one year contract with two options for renwal which allow it run three years if neither side objects. Then it done or it's renewed or it's replaced.

As long noted, the Iraqi military will not be ready to patrol their own air space at the end of 2011 (an issue raised in the press conference). That and Nouri's comments and the comments of others in the Iraqi government indicate that 2011 is not necessarily the end of the Iraq War. Asked at the press conference today, Kirit Radia (ABC News) reports, Lt Gen Frank Helmick stated, "The review of any security agreement with the Iraqi government is up to the government of Iraq and the United States. That is a policy decision that will have to be discussed between the two governments." Sahar Issa and Nancy A. Youssef (McClatchy Newspapers) report, "Iraqi politicians, who are vying for January's scheduled parliamentary elections, want to exert their independence from the Americans. At the Pentagon, commanders are looking for ways to shift resources from former President George W. Bush's war toward Afghanistan, which . . ." Sorry Nancy and Sahar, it's Barack's war. He's president now and it hasn't ended. Not only has it not ended, Barack's operating it under George W. Bush's plan. Barack's continued the Iraq War, he owns it now. In August of 2005, Senator Russ Feingold put foward a proposal people appear to have forgotten today: December 2006 as the target date for US troops to withdraw fully (not just 'combat' troops). That's fifteen months. It's do-able. Barack, who promised at first to have "troops" (in his rah-rah speeches, he didn't specify "combat troops") out in sixteen months and then promised they'd be out in ten. Those are do-able as well. Largely forgotten is that, when running for president in 1972, George McGovern had a plan for withdrawing ALL US troops from Vietnam in six weeks. It was do-able -- and the US had many more service members in Vietnam and much, much more equipment so all US forces could be withdrawan today in six weeks. Instead of using any of those options, Barack's elected to continue the illegal war and, apparently tired from all of his photo shoots, didn't have time to come up with his own plan so he's continuing Bully Boy's Bush's. But it's his war now. And that sentence? It's not reporting. It might belong in a column -- which would be opinion -- but "At the Pentagon, commanders are looking for ways to shift resources from former President George W. Bush's war toward Afghanistan" does not belong in reporting. It is inaccurate. A war continuing seven months after Bush left the White House is no longer his war. That's reality and it's that sort of bulls**t that goes to the press love of Barack Obama. That's why they're considered biased and they should be considered biased when they're foolish enough to try to pass that off as reporting.

In Barack Obama's illegal war today, many were reported dead.

Bombings?

Sahar Issa (McClatchy Newspapers) reports a Baghdad motorcycle bombing which claimed 2 lives and left four people injured, a Mosul roadside bombing which claimed the life of 1 Iraqi solider and left five more wounded and, dropping back to yesterday, a Mosul roadside bombing which claimed the life of 1 Iraqi soldier and left four more injured. Sami al-Jumaili, Michael Christie and Richard Williams (Reuters) report Babel bombings and possible mortar attacks which claimed 7 lives and left fifty-five people injured based on police reports and they note "there appeared to have been at least three blasts."

Shootings?

Sahar Issa (McClatchy Newspapers) reports a Wednesday night attack on a Nineveh checkpoint which claimed the life of 1 police officer and left three more wounded.

Corpses?

Sahar Issa (McClatchy Newspapers) reports the corpses of 5 "members of the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan" (Jalal Talabani's political party) were discovered today following their kidnapping this morning.

Monday Human Rights Watch released a report entitled "'They Want Us Exterminated': Murder, Torture, Sexual Orientation and Gender in Iraq." For the 67-page report [PDF format warning] click here. At the Guardian, HRW's Scott Long explains:

Across Iraq, a killing campaign has spread since early this year. Armed gangs have kidnapped men and tortured them, leaving castrated and mutilated bodies dumped in the garbage or in front of morgues. In April, during a Human Rights Watch research trip to Iraq, men told us tales of death threats, blackmail, midnight raids by masked men on private homes and abductions from the streets. The targets? Men suspected of being gay, or of not being "masculine" enough in their killers' eyes.
Most survivors pointed to Moqtada al-Sadr's Mahdi army, the largest Shia militia in Iraq, as the driving force behind the killings. Sadrist mosques and leaders have warned loudly that homosexuality threatens Iraqi life and culture – though even some Sunni militias may have joined the violence, competing to show their moral credentials. No one can yet give an accurate tally of the victims, but some say the dead may number in the hundreds.
Police and prosecutors ignore the murders. Infiltrated by militias, fearing for their reputations if they defend "effeminate" men, government officials give the killers virtually complete impunity. One 21-year-old even told us how interior ministry forces kidnapped him in February, believing that gay people had access to western money. They tortured him and raped him repeatedly over three weeks, until he managed to raise cash to pay for his freedom. He says he saw the bodies of five other gay men whom the police killed because they could not pay.

Scott Long explained to Deutsche Welle earlier this week, "Iraq's leaders are supposed to defend all Iraqis, not abandon them to armed agents of hate. Turning a blind eye to torture and murder threatens the rights and life of every Iraqi." Weighing in on the report, Chris Floyd (Empire Burlesque) observes:

Yes, when you destroy a society by aggressive war, when you kill more than one million innocent people (out of a total population of 25 million: a kill rate of one out of every 25 Iraqis), when you dispossess four million innocent people, when you join with your local puppets in a savage war of ethnic cleansing, when through invasion and prior years of near-genocidal sanctions you eviscerate one of the most secular states in the Middle East, when you empower violent religious extremists to further your own agenda of domination, this is what you get: the eruption of the human mind's most savage instincts and blind fears, set loose in a maelstrom of degradation.
And still, the urbane, educated, civilized, "progressive" president can stand before the world and declare that America's military rapine of Iraq is
"an extraordinary achievement." And so it is. And so was the Holocaust, the Inquisition, the Trail of Tears, the liquidation of the "kulaks" and many other epiphanies of human civilization. But to be extraordinarily evil is not usually considered something to brag about. That Obama can do so without batting an eye is a telling indication of moral degradation of our own society.

Yesterday's snapshot noted the attempts in England to deport a gay Iraqi male. Jessica Green (Pink News) reports, "Liberal Democrat MP for Brent Sarah Teather, who has championed the case of her constituent, has said the news means it is more likely he will be killed if he is deported. The man, who has not been named to protect his safety, was due to be deported in February after it was ruled he would be safe in Iraq. His lawyers won a judicial review and the case is currently being considered by Home Office ministers. He originally applied for asylum in 2001." And he'll be safe, the government is maintaining, because he can be "discreet." UK government documents advise that he should be able "to conduct such relationships in private on his return to Iraq." Yes, they really are that damn stupid or uncaring. They really are. Meanwhile Chris Jai Centeno (The Advocate) reports, "Gay Iraqis seeking refugee status in Sweden are being barred by the government amid protests from human rights activists advocating for cessation of deportations of asylum seekers on the basis of sexual orientation and gender."

"There comes a time when silence is betrayal" is one of two quotes by MLK that Cindy Sheehan notes in "We Have the Moral High Ground" (Cindy's Soapbox) and the silence on the targeting of Iraq's LGBT community is a betrayal. But she's commenting on another one and that's the left that came down with a severe case of laryngitis:

I remember back in the good ol' days of 2005 and 2006 when being against the wars was not only politically correct, but it was very popular. I remember receiving dozens of awards, uncountable accolades and even was nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize.
Those were the halcyon days of the anti-war movement before the Democrats took over the government (off of the backs of the anti-war movement) and it became anathema to be against the wars and I became unpopular on all sides. I guess at that point, I could have gone with the flow and pretended to support the violence so I could remain popular, but I think I have to fiercely hold on to my core values whether I am "liked" or not.
Killing is wrong no matter if it is state-sanction murder or otherwise. Period. Not too much more to say on that subject, except what I quote above from Dr. King.
However, while the so-called left is obsessed over supporting a very crappy Democratic health care plan, people in far away countries are being deprived of their health and very lives by the Obama Regime's continuation of Bush's ruinous foreign policy.

Smug US official feeds into Iraqi paranoia in wake of bombings

The deadly bombings Wednesday in Baghdad near two key government ministries raise questions about whether U.S. and Iraqi officials have moved too quickly to dismantle many of the security steps that brought about a dramatic drop in bloodshed in the Iraqi capital in the last two years.
Neither American officials in Washington nor Iraqi officials in Baghdad seemed willing to entertain bringing U.S. troops back into the city, however, even as violence has risen over the last two months.
Iraqi politicians, who are vying for January's scheduled parliamentary elections, want to exert their independence from the Americans. At the Pentagon, commanders are looking for ways to shift resources from former President George W. Bush's war toward Afghanistan, which President Barack Obama this week called "fundamental to the defense of our people."


The above is from Sahar Issa and Nancy A. Youssef's "Baghdad bombings question: Did U.S. draw back too fast?" (McClatchy Newspapers). Yesterday's massive bombings in Baghdad have people scrambling to figure out their meaning. Jake Tapper and Karen Travers (ABC News) report:

Responding to the wave of explosions in Iraq today, a Senior Administration official tells ABC News that the attacks -- which have killed at least 75 people -- "indicate the depths these opponents will go in their attempts to destabilize Iraq. The indiscriminate nature of the attacks -- and the blatant killing of innocent Muslims -- is disconcerting."
The official adds that "at the same time, we believe these attacks will energize our Iraqi partners to continue their efforts to build Iraq."
Note the spin at the end that this will energize Iraqi troops, not scare them off -- not a view held by all observers of the conflict.


What is that, Scared Stupid? It's certainly stupid on the part of the US government to make statements like that. Iraq's attempting to apportion blame. Iraqis are not fond of the US to begin with. The violence follows Nouri floating that Iraqis might be able to vote on the Status Of Forces Agreement -- with most assuming that means the SOFA would be terminated (twelve months after official notice was given). That's followed with bombings -- coordinated bombings? That reveal just how inept Iraqi security forces currently are. And a US official wants to make that statement?

Barack Obama needs to ask whomever made that statement to step forward and resign.

Does no one pay attention to the level of paranoia in Baghdad? (Some of it warranted -- such as when British forces were found with bombs and dressed as Muslims.) When Iraqi Christians are targeted in northern Iraq, there's a group that thinks A, a group that thinks B and a group that thinks it must be the Kurdish pesh merga because they must be attempting to make Iraqi Christians think only they can save them.

Kurdish leaders always deny that charge. It's certainly never been backed up with anything empirical. However, it remains one of the popular hypothesis among Iraqis whenever Iraqi Christians are attacked in northern Iraq -- whenever any minority population is attacked in northern Iraq.

And Iraqis have been quoted throughout this illegal war blaming the US for bombings -- not just in a "If they weren't here, this wouldn't be happening," but also in a 'they are secretly behind it.'

When something horrific happens, it is human nature to attempt to construct a narrative and to apportion blame -- especially to apportion blame because without blame, it could (scary thought!) happen to any of us at any time. So the (false) 'teachable moment' is constructed.

The reason, there's always a reason
Behind the reason
When you look for a reason
A reason, I can give you a reason
And maybe you'll think
It's a really good reason
But I come up with the reasons
-- "The Reason," lyrics by Carly Simon, music by Carly Simon and Danny Kortchmar, first appears on her Letters Never Sent album

So in that climate, you do not need an American government official looking at the bombings and seeing 'benefits'. Such an official encourages charges and hatred and it won't be his or her butt in Iraq, it will be US service members and diplomatic staff who will have to deal with the fall out. If Stephen Biddle (whom I loathe) made that statement, it wouldn't matter. He's a private citizen. But when a government official makes it, the statement carries more weight and, considering the climate in Iraq, it was an irresponsible remark. Barack should ask the person to step forward and resign or be fired. I don't mean a witch hunt. If the person's not honorable enough to step forward, there are other things to address. But the request should be made and, if the anonymous official has any self-respect, he or she would resign.

Repeating, that is not a "Private citizens should watch what they say." I'm not Ari. A private citizen can say whatever they want. But for a government official to make that statement? It's not helpful and it risks the lives of Americans in Iraq. (It also undermines administration policies but I'm not overly concerned with that. Although the press is still giving the administration a ride, the reality is that by March everything had descended to petty turf wars and there's so much acrimony and rivalry that nothing's going to be accomplished without a serious shake up at the White House. At the White House. This has nothing to do with State or any other department. The departments are largely running fine and, at State, Hillary's really boosted morale. But at the White House, there is no sense of a team and only petty rivalries and never ending scorecards of real and imagined sleights.)

Along with feeding fears, the statements also show a lack of compassion. Adam Ashton (McClatchy Newspapers) notes:

"Where are the police? I lost a brother, and they are sitting in their cars with air conditioning," said Um Khatab, whose 42-year-old brother died when the floor where he worked at the Foreign Ministry collapsed in the day's largest bombing.
Her cries of mourning reverberated in the street while teams of police officers sifted through the site, making their way past burnt-out cars and scorched pavement.

That woman has enough to deal with. She doesn't also need some smug, US government official trying to turn her tragedy into a 'teachable moment.' Sam Dagher (New York Times) reports:

A senior Shiite politician went on Iraqiya to call on Mr. Maliki to fire the security and intelligence officials responsible for the areas that were attacked.
"We must punish those who made mistakes," said the politician, Hadi al-Ameri.


Accountability shouldn't just be for Iraqis.

In their editorial "Violence in Iraq: The limits of restraint," the Guardian estimates that almost 700 Iraqis have died since the June 30th (limited) handover and (limited) pull-back.

The cocky reaction of Iraqi generals and police chiefs when the Americans began their withdrawal to the sidelines looks pretty overblown in retrospect. Not only could they handle security as well as the Americans, some of these officers implied, they could handle it better with the foreigners out of the way. Now the Iraqi forces are face to face with their own deficiencies. Major General Qassim al-Moussawi, one of their commanders, was reduced yesterday to saying on state television that they "must take most of the blame". American journalists, reporting in recent weeks on the few joint operations that the two armies are now conducting, have picked up on the many bad habits that the training programmes have failed to eradicate, from slackness in patrolling to knocking off for tea at inappropriate moments. In a report which caused a stir when it became public two weeks ago, Colonel Timothy Reese, a senior US military adviser, listed corruption, poor management, lack of initiative, and failure to resist pressure from Shia political parties as unhappy characteristics of the Iraqi security forces.

"There comes a time when silence is betrayal" is one of two quotes by MLK that Cindy Sheehan notes in "We Have the Moral High Ground" (Cindy's Soapbox):

I remember back in the good ol' days of 2005 and 2006 when being against the wars was not only politically correct, but it was very popular. I remember receiving dozens of awards, uncountable accolades and even was nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize.
Those were the halcyon days of the anti-war movement before the Democrats took over the government (off of the backs of the anti-war movement) and it became anathema to be against the wars and I became unpopular on all sides. I guess at that point, I could have gone with the flow and pretended to support the violence so I could remain popular, but I think I have to fiercely hold on to my core values whether I am "liked" or not.
Killing is wrong no matter if it is state-sanction murder or otherwise. Period. Not too much more to say on that subject, except what I quote above from Dr. King.
However, while the so-called left is obsessed over supporting a very crappy Democratic health care plan, people in far away countries are being deprived of their health and very lives by the Obama Regime's continuation of Bush's ruinous foreign policy.

We'll close with the opening of Sherwood Ross' "Congress Shirks Its Responsibility, Allows White House to Make Wars" (New Zealand's Scoop):

On occasion, critics of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars have questioned, with good reason, whether the American war in Afghanistan has been carried far beyond what Congress authorized. This raises a fundamental question that has bedeviled the country since 1950.
Although the Constitution requires Congress to make the decision to go to war and to decide the kind of war to be fought (navel, land, air), since the Korean conflict it has largely abdicated that responsibility to the president, says a law school dean and authority on the issue. The result has been more frequent (and frequently misguided) wars, than there would have been had Congress done its duty.
"Since 1950, the constitutional plan (of America’s founders) has been destroyed, and the power to start wars without a previous Congressional declaration or authorization has been claimed by every President except Eisenhower," says Lawrence Velvel, dean of the Masachusetts School of Law at Andover.
The framers of the Constitution put the decision-making power on war in Congress because "they felt that war was a disaster and the Executive was too prone to war," Velvel said. Today, with regard to war "we have inverted the constitutional plan, and war is decided upon not by Congress, but by the President."
Velvel, who has written extensively on the issue, said the only power the Founders left to the President was his authority to repel an immediate attack on American lives, property or territory---a power he cannot lawfully inflate into a continuing war. The Founders "deliberately rejected the British system in which the king made the decision to go to war, with his powers being facilitated because he had a standing army, could provide navies, and could raise monies for the armed services," Velvel pointed out.


The e-mail address for this site is common_ills@yahoo.com.










sam dagher


cindy sheehan