Chump's still hiding low. Two scandals swirling in the news cycle and he's trying to avoid them. On ABC's THIS WEEK, Martha Raddatz noted Chump's latest scandal at the start of the program:
ANNOUNCER: From ABC News, it’s “THIS WEEK.” Here now, Martha Raddatz.
RADDATZ: Good morning and welcome to “THIS WEEK.” This morning, millions of Americans remain stranded or facing canceled or delayed flights after the unprecedented nationwide ground stop. For hours on Friday, with thousands of planes still in the sky, we were all left in the dark about what was happening and what might have caused the massive and historic shutdown. This morning, the administration is pointing the finger at a contractor upgrading the system, saying it was an error or faulty equipment. But major questions remain. How could an error like that cascade through nearly the entire system? And could it happen again? We will talk with the transportation secretary, Sean Duffy, in a moment. First, we take you inside those chaotic few hours, the evolving explanations from officials and the ripple effect still being felt this morning after word of the shutdown rocked the nation.
(BEGIN VIDEOTAPE)
RADDATZ (voice over): This morning, hundreds of thousands of Americans remain stranded at airports across the country following Friday’s alarming nationwide ground stop. At 3:54 p.m. Eastern, pilots preparing to depart told to return to the gate immediately.
ATC: Attention all aircraft waiting for departure. National ground stop update unknown.
RADDATZ (voice over): Lasting nearly four and a half hours, it was the longest nationwide ground stop since 9/11, and only the third this century.
BRYAN BEDFORD, FAA ADMINISTRATOR: Tens of thousands of Americans had their flights disrupted yesterday. And I want you to understand, we did that out of an abundance of caution.
RADDATZ (voice over): The FAA chief, speaking for the first time Saturday morning, apologizing to the American people and standing by the decision to implement the stop.
BEDFORD: We couldn’t explain the instability. And we saw the instability start to propagate into facilities we couldn’t identify. That’s when we made the decision to ground stop out of an abundance of caution. But no facilities went dark.
RADDATZ (voice over): Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, placing the blame on government contractor L3Harris while upgrading the nation’s aging air traffic control equipment.
SEAN DUFFY, TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY: A contractor was doing routine maintenance to switch telecommunication lines from old copper wire, and they were bringing it over to fiber. Either through contractor error or a faulty piece of equipment, that router that was being replaced as we switched from copper to fiber, it started flooding other routers in our air traffic control system.
RADDATZ (voice over): But Duffy, acknowledging, they are still unsure what exactly caused the router overload.
DUFFY: What we’re working to determine was whether we had incompetence, meaning was it user error or installator (ph) error from L3Harris, or did they install a faulty router?
RADDATZ (voice over): The FAA administration ruled out any cyberattack.
BEDFORD: We see zero evidence of anything nefarious and zero evidence of anything A.I. related.
RADDATZ (voice over): But that explanation was a far cry from the confusing joint press conference Friday night after the ground stop was lifted.
MARKWAYNE MULLIN, HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY: So, let’s talk about cybersecurity. Once again, we’re still looking at it. We’re not ruling out anything. What it appears to be right now is, as Secretary Duffy and FAA was going in and putting patches into the system, they were putting new equipment and new technology and that new equipment, new technology just wasn’t -- it was overwhelming the older system.
DUFFY: This is all the old legacy equipment. All of the new equipment that’s been deployed did not go down.
RADDATZ (voice over): That explanation coming more than four hours after the ground stop began, which has resulted in more than 17,000 flights canceled since Friday, according to FlightAware. Chaos unfolding at airports from coast to coast.
UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: This is an all-day thing and going nowhere.
UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Everyone’s checked bag is stuck. No one can touch it. And they’re saying that we should just go home without it.
UNIDENTIFIED MALE: I just want to get back home to my wife.
RADDATZ (voice over): With planes frozen on runways and passengers stuck on board. Duffy making the case for Congress to pass $50 billion in funding to finish upgrading the entire air traffic control system. The Transportation secretary also appearing to blame his predecessors.
DUFFY: Now, if you look to the past administrations, going back 25 years, $15 billion has been given to the FAA to fix this air traffic control system. And guess what? Barely anything was done.
RADDATZ (voice over): Former Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg, brushing off criticism.
PETE BUTTIGIEG, FORMER TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY: We did a lot to upgrade the system. When we had an outage, I didn’t stand there complaining about the Trump administration. We got to work.
RADDATZ (voice over): Now, ahead of the busiest travel week of the year over the Thanksgiving holiday, officials insisting the worst is over.
If we look to the past administrations going back 25 years? Sean Duffy does know that from January 2017 through January 2021, Chump was in the White House, right? He does get that his criticism includes Chump, right? On CBS' FACE THE NATION, Margaret Brennan noted, "So the union that represents aviation safety specialists, PASS, as they're called, said the issue was isolated to two contractor-owned-and-maintained routers that were being updated in the middle of the day, and they said their technicians were not involved in the upgrades."
On CNN NEWSROOM, this was noted:
BRIAN TODD, CNN CORRESPONDENT: There's been a bizarre and somewhat uncharacteristic silence from President Trump regarding the, the ground stops at America's airports and the chaos surrounding air travel in the U.S. The president has not spoken out publicly at all on Friday or Saturday on the situation, and he's not posted anything on Truth Social about it. Instead, he's fired off posts regarding plans to revitalize Hollywood, and criticisms of California Governor Gavin Newsom. A White House official does tell us that the president has been receiving constant updates on the air travel situation. But even with all of that, we do have new reporting from our colleague, Kit Maher, who cites a source familiar with the matter as saying that the president has corresponded with Republican Senator Eric Schmitt several times over the past few months about legislation to modernize America's air traffic control centers control towers, terminals, and other infrastructure, a plan to ask for about $30 billion in additional funding from Congress.
[. . .]
Now, while Sean Duffy has been critical of Congress for funding and critical of the contractor involved in the ground stop problems, there is criticism for Sean Duffy himself. New York Governor Kathy Hochul has called for Duffy to either resign or be removed by President Trump. She said on Saturday that the air traffic controller shortages, the communications problems, have all become a pattern under Duffy's watch, and quote, through it all, he's been more focused on starring in his own reality show than addressing the crisis at his agency, end quote.
That's Chump's most recent scandal. The one right before it? The one regarding national security? ABC's THIS WEEK covered it today:
MARTHA RADDATZ: Chief business correspondent Rebecca Jarvis has the story.
(BEGIN VIDEOTAPE)
REBECCA JARVIS, ABC NEWS CHIEF BUSINESS CORRESPONDENT (voice-over): This week, the stunning fall of the most consequential player in the A.I. revolution.
JENSEN HUANG, FORMER NVIDIA CEO: Here it is.
JARVIS (voice-over): Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang, whose computer chips power the data centers behind artificial intelligence, resigning Thursday after admitting to an extramarital affair reported by "The New York Times" to have been with Alice Huang, a woman the U.S. intelligence community believes is an intelligence asset for China. At first, the Nvidia boss was determined to stay at the company, writing in an apology e-mail last Sunday to employees, "I am fully committed to Nvidia and will work to earn back your confidence." That didn't happen. In subsequent days, reports Jensen Huang had at least one additional affair with an employee at Nvidia. His resignation followed. But it's Huang's connection to Alice Huang, the alleged Chinese spy, that has rocked the company and the A.I. world. Alice Huang was a top executive at Megaspeed, a Singapore based company with access to Nvidia's top tier computer chips that are banned from being imported into China. Chinese firms circumvent that ban by relying on data centers in Southeast Asia to access the computing power of those chips without needing the physical hardware. Nvidia's chief has been photographed with Alice Huang since as early as 2024, when the U.S. began investigating Megaspeed for potentially smuggling those industry-leading chips into China, according to “The New York Times”. China has denied those allegations. U.S. intelligence was also tracking the relationship. Sources telling ABC News, Secretary of State Marco Rubio briefed the president about the relationship on Air Force One en route to China in May, the second time Rubio warned Trump about the alleged plot, according to sources. Trump asked Jensen Huang to join that trip, with the NVIDIA chief flying on Air Force One. Trump this week denying that he knew of the alleged affair at the time of the trip.
DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: No, I didn't hear about it then, but a lot of people have heard about it, and Jensen totally denies that.
JARVIS (voice-over): Trump says he spoke to Jensen Huang on Monday and asked him about Alice Huang.
TRUMP: I asked him that question, “Did you have any idea that she was a spy?” He said, “I had no idea that she was a spy,” and I really believe him.
JARVIS (voice-over): But the president hedging when asked if resigning was the right move.
TRUMP: If the woman was a spy, yes. If the woman was not a spy, perhaps it would be different. But I can tell you this, somehow, he'll end up in his feet.
JARVIS (voice-over): The saga also exposing a rift inside the administration, with Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent placing blame on the Commerce Department for failing to place Megaspeed on an export blacklist.
SCOTT BESSENT, TREASURY SECRETARY: Treasury, War, USTR, and State, they were in favor of putting Megaspeed on the entity list for months. But Commerce has the pen, Commerce BIS has the pen, and you will has -- have to ask them about their internal processes.
JARVIS (voice-over): Last year, Huang shared a stage with Lutnick and touted their close relationship.
JENSEN HUANG, FORMER NVIDIA CEO: Howard is the person I talk to most in the administration.
(END VIDEOTAPE)
On FACE THE NATION (CBS), Margaret Brennan spoke with US House Rep Jim Himes:
MARGARET BRENNAN: I want to ask you about what is happening with this arms race with China and chips. You were one of the rest of the Gang of Eight who were briefed this past week on what is going on with Nvidia, that chipmaker. CBS has reported, U.S. intelligence agencies believe Alice Huang, the Megaspeed CEO who was linked to Jensen Huang of Nvidia, was indeed an asset of China's Ministry of State Security. However, when President Trump was asked about the scandal, he put it this way:
(Begin VT)
DONALD TRUMP (President of the United States): The big thing is, was the woman a spy? And I don't know if that's been determined yet. But if the woman was a spy, yes. If the woman was not a spy, perhaps it would be different.
(End VT)
MARGARET BRENNAN: So, how certain is U.S. intelligence that she was an asset of Chinese intelligence, and is that the central issue?
REPRESENTATIVE JIM HIMES: Margaret, I don't – I don't even know how to respond to the president's statement. Remember, it was March when – or March or April when the secretary of state, Marco Rubio, circulated a memo to all of the senior people, including presumably the White House, saying, we have concerns that this woman is a spy. It is now November, and the president of the United States had no interest in understanding whether, in this most essential technology, the technology which could end millions of jobs or cure cancer, and/or create, you know, a real tool for terrorists and – you know, I mean, the fact that the president in November is saying we don't know if she's a spy, that – that actually sort of perfectly illustrates my concern. Now, here's what I can tell you based on what I know. I don't think that we know. I don't think that we know. And when we say spy, spy is a pretty imprecise term, right? It's possible, based on what I know, that Alice Huang had no idea that she was maybe being monitored or – or – or working for the Chinese. That's possible. We don't know the answer to that question. It's also possible, on the other end of the spectrum, that she was a fully paid-up, you know, intelligence asset and actually communicating. But the point of all of this is, how is it possible that we don't know this around the single most important technology of our lifetime? So, as you might imagine, Margaret, I'm going to spend a lot of time getting to the bottom of this. And I'm happy to report that, actually, as you've observed, Republicans in Congress are interested too.
MARGARET BRENNAN: They are indeed. You referenced there a memo. CNN reported Marco Rubio, as national security adviser and secretary of state, drafted this based on CIA intelligence and then briefed the president. It also drew on intercepted communications between Alice Huang and Jensen Huang. Has that memo been shared with the Gang of Eight?
REPRESENTATIVE JIM HIMES: That memo has not been shared. And, again, the only information that has come our way – and I'm speaking, I think, on behalf of the whole Congress here because I was with the Gang of Eight last week. The only information that has come our way was sort of a glancing, not-on-the-agenda discussion in that meeting. So we have a lot of work to do. But, I mean, the fundamental question is, number one, has the FBI – and I don't know the answer to this question. The FBI, as you know, is the entity that does this counterintelligence work, figuring out what Alice Huang is and what she sent to the Chinese, if anything, right? We don't know that. We don't know if they launched an investigation. We're worried about it, right, because the president and his buddy-buddies, and apparently Howard Lutnick, the commerce secretary, who has responsibility for keeping chips that could help build, you know, Chinese AI out of China, you know, these guys are palling around. Jensen Huang is, you know, writing $25 million checks for the ballroom. We got to get to the bottom of this, and we're – we haven't even begun to get the facts we need here.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Two law enforcement sources told CBS that DOJ's National Security Division is investigating Megaspeed. That's the Singapore company that Alice Huang was CEO of. She's since left that position, as I understand it. And they're looking at that. But it sounds like you are also saying Jensen Huang needs to be looked at with more scrutiny here, and whether he was indeed a target. If – if he was a target of Chinese intelligence, why wouldn't the United States tell him that?
REPRESENTATIVE JIM HIMES: Well, let's take that piece by piece. Megaspeed is an entity that sort of didn't exist 10 years ago in any meaningful way. And now they appear – and I want to say appear – to be doing possibly two things. Number one, they may be a way of getting these chips to China. You know, Nvidia could sell them to Megaspeed, Megaspeed gives them to China. Or, more interestingly, and we know that this goes on, China wants to train its models so it doesn't even buy the chips, but it just uses Megaspeed's data centers, right? So, China is, you know, training up their frontier models simply online, if you will, right? So that's the question around Megaspeed. The question around Alice Huang is what – you know, was she a witting agent of the Chinese government, or was she just sort of being monitored? And then the really important question is, what information – and – and this is where you know Mr. Huang, Jensen Huang, comes in. What information made its way from the CEO, Jensen, to her to the Chinese? What influence was exerted, right? I mean, if you look at the behavior of the Commerce Department in particular, it looked like somebody was standing up for Nvidia. Why? Was that influence on the part of Jensen Huang? Twenty-five million dollars in money handed over for a ballroom sounds like a pretty good way to build influence, to me, at least.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Has Secretary Lutnick, whose Commerce Department would be in charge of overseeing some of this, did he respond to your request to meet with the Intelligence Committee?
REPRESENTATIVE JIM HIMES: Well, that – that request just went out Friday of last week, so, you know, he – he will respond. And, as you probably know, there's also been a bipartisan request for him to appear in the Banking Committee in the Senate.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Right.
REPRESENTATIVE JIM HIMES: But, again, if you read the reporting here, it looks like he has been the barrier inside the government to stopping the flow of these Nvidia chips to China. And the question is, why?
MARGARET BRENNAN: Well, sort of to that point, I want to ask you about what the treasury secretary – if I could ask you to put your Financial Services hat on for a moment here and bridge both worlds, the treasury secretary was on FOX this morning, and he floated that more Nvidia executives should be removed. He said there's a culture of noncompliance that might need to be looked at, and whether they boosted potentially illicit sales of chips, he – which sort of suggests it's part of a larger smuggling operation that you may have just touched on there. And he cited reporting that only 1 percent of the computer chips imported to Singapore stayed there, even though Nvidia said Singapore accounted for 20 percent of their sales. Now, if a bank were entangled in those kind of activities, there would be very strong action taken. What action needs to be taken here, in terms of answering all these questions the treasury secretary just laid out?
REPRESENTATIVE JIM HIMES: Yes. Yes. So, I mean, let's be super clear here, right? Nvidia makes chips. They get wealthy when they sell chips. So, of course they have an incentive to sell these chips to the Chinese. That's nothing new. Lots of companies would love to sell everything to the Chinese. It's the government's job, it is the commerce secretary's job, and the president's job to stop that from happening through things like the Entity List, which, you know, prohibit American companies from doing business with anybody on that Entity List. Lo and behold, Megaspeed was not on that Entity List. Actually, the treasury secretary has been saying that. But, yes, what you're talking about, were banks facilitating a smuggling operation? I don't know what the treasury secretary was talking about. But, yes, it should not just be Jensen Huang. It needs to be his people, who apparently were doing exactly everything that he – that – that they were told to do. It needs to be the commerce secretary, who was not doing, apparently, according to the treasury secretary, enough. And, yes, if banks were facilitating this stuff, they too, you know, need to be called to account.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Yes, the treasury secretary was very clear that enforcement comes to Commerce, and that Commerce was not taking the action there.
So Huang also donated $25 million to Chump for the ballroom? Was that just like a tip to Chump or was it the motivating factor to look the other way? On ABC'S THIS WEEK, Martha Raddatz spoke about the scandal with Senator Chris Van Hollen:
RADDATZ: I'm joined now by Maryland Democratic Senator Chris Van Hollen, who sits on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and the Banking Committee. He announced this week he's challenging Chuck Schumer for Senate Majority Leader. Good to see you this morning, sir. Let's -- let’s start with NVIDIA. Jensen Huang has agreed to testify in a closed-door hearing, a briefing with the House Foreign Affairs Committee. How concerned are you about this, that this alleged spy might have gained confidential information?
SEN. CHRIS VAN HOLLEN, (D) MARYLAND AND FOREIGN RELATIONS & BANKING COMMITTEES: Well, Martha, it's good to be with you. I'm very concerned about this. This has been part of the corruption of the Trump administration from day one. Jensen Huang and NVIDIA gave $25 million for Donald Trump's gold-plated ballroom. He's been a huge supporter of the president, and he has gotten the president to allow NVIDIA to send very high-end chips to China against the advice of folks in the national security arena. And now we find out that he's had this relationship with a potential spy who's been part of an effort to actually divert these chips from Singapore, other places in Southeast China -- in Southeast Asia to China. So, this is very worrisome. We need to get to the bottom of it.
RADDATZ: As you heard, sources told ABC News that Secretary Rubio informed President Trump of Jensen Huang's relationship before picking up Huang in Alaska on Air Force One and then heading to China. The president denies he knew about it at the time. Do you believe him?
VAN HOLLEN: I do not, because this is a president who lies to the American public all the time. And this is why we need an investigation. We need people testifying under oath.
RADDATZ: So, you do believe he was briefed?
VAN HOLLEN: I do believe he was briefed. I think -- all the information that I've seen suggests that this would not have escaped the attention of the president of the United States.
RADDATZ: “The New York Times” also reporting that President Trump urged Huang on Tuesday to fight to keep his job. Is that appropriate to you?
VAN HOLLEN: Not at all. Here, you have somebody who's been implicated in an effort to smuggle high-end U.S. chips into China, as well as somebody who has been in cahoots with the president from day one by supporting the president, giving him money for different projects, and getting the ability to send these high-end chips in, which compromise our national security and our place in the A.I. race.
RADDATZ: If all of this is true, what can be done now? Obviously, you can do something to him or hold him responsible. But what can be done now in terms -- if there is this national security issue?
VAN HOLLEN: So, first of all, Megaspeed. This is the company that was run by the woman that he had the relationship with. That should be on the entities list. Commerce should have put that on the entities list as soon as they had this information. We also need to close other loopholes in our export control laws, including with a provision that says that if you're a subsidiary of a company that's on the blacklist, you shouldn't be able to export and receive these high-end chips either. So, there are lots of things we can do to close these loopholes.
RADDATZ: The New York Times is also reporting this morning about Howard Lutnick, saying he pushed to weaken CHIP rules that overlapped with his family business. So, is this Secretary Lutnick's fault in your view? If so, should he be fired?
VAN HOLLEN: I think he should be fired. And I chair the subcommittee that oversees the Department of Commerce that helped expose his involvement with the -- with Epstein. And now we have this on top of what we already knew. Yes, he should be fired because this is a case where this company should have been on the entities list. You just heard Bessent say that Treasury had recommended to Commerce that they be put on the entities list. So the question is, why were they not done that? And I think now we're getting the answers through the relationship between the president, Jensen Huang, and now Jensen Huang's girlfriend.
RADDATZ: And what do you think President Trump will do about this? What do you foresee?
VAN HOLLEN: Well, what he should do is actually get to the bottom of it and close these loopholes. What he will do apparently is tell Jensen Huang to fight this effort. So essentially, what the president is doing is once again undermining our national security and giving a green light to the idea that we should send these very high-end chips to China.
On NBC's MEET THE PRESS, moderator Kristen Welker talked about the Nvidia scandal with former US Vice President Mike Pence:
KRISTEN WELKER: You talk about the culture of corruption. I want to talk about that. But start through the lens of the Nvidia crisis. You have CEO Jensen Huang stepping down after it was revealed he had an affair with someone who’s an alleged Chinese spy. President Trump reportedly briefed on the matter all the way back in May. Do you think President Trump is being tough enough on China?
FMR. VICE PRES. MIKE PENCE: Well, Jensen Huang had to go. But it can’t stop there. I mean, the American people deserve answers about how and why Nvidia was permitted to transfer our most advanced AI semiconductors and chip technology to companies that could well then provide them to communist China. But look I, I — first off, to push back, China is the greatest economic and strategic threat facing the United States of America. I know the president’s headed that way again this week. I’m all for diplomacy, but it doesn’t change the reality that China is our, our chief threat and if we don’t take the right steps, it could become an adversary in the years ahead. So I think as you look at this moment, I think it’s extremely important that we get to the bottom of how this happened. We need to find out why, particularly with regard to the Commerce Department there wasn’t greater oversight.
KRISTEN WELKER: You mean investigations? Are you calling for investigations?
FMR. VICE PRES. MIKE PENCE: Look, I think the administration themselves and the American people deserve to understand how this happened. But for me, it’s just as important as you suggested in your question, that we ask why has this Trump administration changed its posture on China so dramatically? You’ll recall that during the first Trump administration, we drew a hard line on China.
MEET THE PRESS also addressed the topic during their roundtable:
KRISTEN WELKER: Welcome back. The panel is here. NBC News national security managing editor Carol Lee; Steve Ricchetti, former counselor to President Biden; and former Republican Congressman Carlos Curbelo of Florida. Welcome to all of you. [. . .] Carol, all of this taking place, the backdrop this week, this breaking news on Nvidia. We heard Mike Pence say he wants answers. He wants to get to the bottom of this. All of it as President Trump prepares to go to China to meet with President Xi Jinping. What are your sources telling you there?
CAROL LEE: Well, there’s concern that there could be more to come out. And there’s real concern about what the risks are to national security. And that has fallen into several different tracks. One, what did China gain from having this alleged by in an affair with Jensen Huang? And China denies that, but U.S. intelligence says that. The President Trump question: Why did President Trump apparently not do anything once he learned what U.S. intelligence had picked up, including he continued having a close relationship with Jensen Huang and he took him on Air Force One on the way to China at that same time. And then there’s this concern about China getting access to these advanced chips. And there is bipartisan support for restricting that further. That’s been amplified throughout all of this. But it’s not clear where the president is for all the reasons that Vice President Pence laid out.
KRISTEN WELKER: Yeah. Carlos, the president’s going to meet with President Xi. Should he raise the issue?
FMR REP. CARLOS CURBELO: Well, Kristen, what’s remarkable about this is that Donald Trump is the man who introduced China’s skepticism into American politics. And by the way, he did so very successfully, and I think it was justified, right? The Chinese have not been fair competitors for a very long time. So here’s the man who builds this national consensus. The Biden administration followed a lot of the Trump policies on China, and now the administration is sending these mixed signals with a major official, Secretary Lutnick, apparently facilitating financial transactions for China.
KRISTEN WELKER: Steve, quickly, how do you see it?
STEVE RICCHETTI: I am encouraged to see that there is bipartisan concern about the national security implications of what this represents. So there’s going to be hearings, oversight investigation. And I think it will be welcome.
KRISTEN WELKER: Yeah, there’s going to be hearings, including with Jensen Huang, as well as Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, so we’ll watch all of that very closely. Thank you all so very much for a great conversation. Really appreciate it. That is all for today. Thank you so much for watching. We’ll be back next week, because if it’s Sunday, it’s Meet the Press.
Lastly, on GPS (CNN), Fareed Zakaria addressed the topic:
ZAKARIA: On Thursday, Jensen Huang resigned as the CEO of the chip designer Nvidia, a massive mover in the A.I. world. His departure came after U.S. officials said they believed he was having an affair with a potential Chinese intelligence asset, Alice Huang, of the Singapore based firm Megaspeed. China has dismissed the allegations as slander. For more, I am joined by Julian Gewirtz, who was senior director for China and Taiwan on President Biden's national Security Council. Welcome, Julian.
JULIAN GEWIRTZ, FORMER CHINA AND TAIWAN SENIOR DIRECTOR, NATIONAL SECURITY COUNCIL: Great to be here.
ZAKARIA: So, we know about spying from the Cold War and the Soviet -- you know, we know the Soviet Union used spy a lot. We know we spy a lot. What about China? Is there a history of espionage?
GEWIRTZ: Absolutely. You know, the reality is that espionage is as much a part of the Chinese communist party's DNA as communism itself. From the very beginning, this is an organization that was born underground. So infiltration, spying, these kind of plots were a core part of how they survived from the very beginning. And there are extraordinary stories from the Chinese civil war of them infiltrating their enemies at very high levels. You know, in one case, Mao was hiding out in the caves and the enemy general who was plotting an attack had an aide who passed the battle plans to Mao. And Mao said this was worth several divisions in a military fight. So when we think about the story of Alice Huang and Jensen Huang, it's very much a part of that history.
ZAKARIA: There's a -- there's a story you were telling me about a Peking opera star, a Beijing opera star, wouldn't you say? Tell that story.
GEWIRTZ: Yes. You know, so in this history, some of these stories are almost, you know, sort of impossible to believe. But in this case, there was a French diplomat who was in China for many years and developed a relationship with this opera singer and believed, actually that they had a child together.
But decades later, it was discovered that this relationship had involved him passing intelligence to the Chinese side, and that the opera singer was actually a man in disguise. It's kind of incredible. So, you know, in this case, you know, we see that this history really shows that there's nothing that the Chinese communist party won't try in seeking to gain an espionage advantage.
ZAKARIA: What in this case is the nature of the economic espionage that they would want? Because, you know, as I see it, Jensen Huang believes in selling the Chinese chips anyway. He convinced Donald Trump that he should sell them those -- anyway. So what would they have been trying to get?
GEWIRTZ: Yes. Well, so the number one thing that China wanted from Jensen Huang clearly was access to those in Nvidia chips that, as you said, are so essential to the A.I. boom happening. Yes, here in the United States, but also very much in China. You know, the official position of the Chinese Communist Party is that they don't need those chips. They're indigenizing them, that they're fine. But in fact, as we know, they have been obtaining, Chinese companies have been obtaining chips from data centers in Southeast Asia and also through smuggling. And Alice Huang, the woman with whom Jensen Huang had an affair, is at the center of some of that kind of activity. And so, that's the number one thing they wanted. But there's another point, which is very important, which is that Jensen Huang has been President Trump's very important advisor on A.I., on China, and in shaping policy here in the United States. And so, they clearly also wanted the kind of information and potentially even the influence that only an advisor of that sort can have.
ZAKARIA: You say in your Atlantic article, which is very, very well done, that this is a very dangerous sort of arrangement that the Trump administration has -- where the president has these very close personal relationships with these very powerful people, because the interests of those corporate CEOs are not always the same as the interests of the United States.
GEWIRTZ: Exactly. So, you know, one of the really striking developments in the Trump administration has been this extraordinary reliance on private sector leaders, Jensen Huang, Elon Musk, many others, who control incredible power in our economy particularly around A.I. And the Trump administration, has been treating them as if almost they're government ministers, you know, senior advisors who are part of decision making, come on foreign trips, including President Trump's last trip to China he brought along this set of people. And what we see there is, of course, these executives have their own interests. The interests of their companies are quite different in some cases from the national interest of the United States. So, it's deeply concerning that the Trump administration is so reliant on them to shape policy. And candidly, the Jensen Huang situation, this scandal is far bigger than any one individual and his infidelities, because really, what has been revealed through this is that the Department of Commerce has not been enforcing regulations. The Trump administration has been quite willing to let American national security go by the wayside here to preserve these relationships with high level executives.
ZAKARIA: You were just in Singapore. How are they reacting to all this? Alice Huang's company is based in Singapore.
GEWIRTZ: Well, one of the really extraordinary things here is that the Singaporean government, which, as you know, is normally a very circumspect and careful set of officials, has issued a statement saying that they did not get good cooperation from the United States, from the Department of Justice, in investigating Alice Huang, who was in Singapore and whose passport that they had seized. And this is really striking, really startling in its way, because for the Singaporean government to say this means that they are quite worried that perhaps their own reputation could somehow be besmirched by this, and that they are themselves likely quite concerned about what was going on in the United States. So, again, one of the areas where we need to have Congress and others ask very hard questions is, why was the case of Alice Huang, suspected to be a Chinese asset, not prioritized more seriously when so much is at stake here?
ZAKARIA: So the real scandal is not really about what Jensen Huang did. It's what the U.S. government did not do.
GEWIRTZ: Exactly. That's certainly my view. And I think when we look back on this period in history, of course, there's been a tremendous amount of attention on Jensen Huang and his personal dalliances. And, you know, as you said, he's stepped down now. But the reason that that really is just the end of act one is that there are so many unanswered questions. For instance, did Nvidia sell more chips to Megaspeed, the company that Alice Huang was associated with, then it would have otherwise? They get to make allocation decisions. Also, as you say, what was the U.S. government doing? The Department of Commerce knew that this company was led by someone who. Parts of the U.S. government suspected was a Chinese asset, and yet for months, they sat on that information and let the chips flow. And we're in a very serious competition with China on artificial intelligence. And that kind of oversight can be something that gives China a significant edge.
Let's wind down with this from Senator Adam Schiff:
Washington, D.C. – U.S. Senators Adam Schiff (D-Calif.) and Alex Padilla (D-Calif.) along with Representatives Juan Vargas (D-Calif.-52), Sara Jacobs (D-Calif.-51), Mike Levin (D-Calif.-49), and Scott Peters (D-Calif.-50) demanded answers from the Trump Administration after an eight-year-old Haitian child who lost Temporary Protected Status earlier this year was taken into federal custody after an immigration check-in in San Diego.
“An ICE officer reportedly invoked the William Wilberforce Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act of 2008 while taking him into custody, apparently placing the child in restraints and separating him from the person who brought him for his hearing. Video footage appears to show the use of restraints on a child who seemed to pose no threat to those around him, raising serious questions about the handling of this incident,” wrote the lawmakers. “We express concerns about the basis for this action and the harm it may cause a young child who appeared for his required hearing.”
“With this letter, we emphasize that the safety and well-being of children and families in San Diego County must remain the highest priority,” the lawmakers continued. “We also request confirmation on the child’s whereabouts, whether his family is aware of his location, and what steps your agencies are taking to ensure he can be reunited with them.”
Read the full letter here and below.
Dear Secretary Mullin and Secretary Kennedy,
We write to express deep concerns regarding reports that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detained an eight-year-old Haitian child at a scheduled immigration hearing in San Diego, California, on November 5, 2026. An ICE officer reportedly invoked the William Wilberforce Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act of 2008 while taking him into custody, apparently placing the child in restraints and separating him from the person who brought him for his hearing. Video footage appears to show the use of restraints on a child who seemed to pose no threat to those around him, raising serious questions about the handling of this incident. We express concerns about the basis for this action and the harm it may cause a young child who appeared for his required hearing before the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR).
Our September 22, 2026, letter concerning ICE enforcement activity around school and educational institutions addressed the fear and disruption these actions cause in our communities. House Members of the San Diego congressional delegation also wrote to both the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and Department of Education on October 14, 2025, highlighting concerns from twenty-five San Diego County school district superintendents. The superintendents requested DHS to adopt clear consistent enforcement policies and coordination between the departments to keep schools safe places to learn. This reported detention underscores those concerns. Following this third-grade student’s detention, San Diego Unified School District reportedly sent crisis counselors to Fay Elementary School to support his classmates, who expressed fear and distress. The effects of this action extend far beyond one child and his family.
With this letter, we emphasize that the safety and well-being of children and families in San Diego County must remain the highest priority. We will continue to monitor this situation closely and expect timely updates on the child’s well-being and your agencies’ response to these concerns. We also request confirmation on the child’s whereabouts, whether his family is aware of his location, and what steps your agencies are taking to ensure he can be reunited with them. We ask that you promptly review this child’s case and give it your full and fair consideration based on its merits, consistent with all applicable laws, rules, and regulations. Please provide our offices with an update regarding your findings from this review by December 1, 2026.
###
Kat's "Kat's Korner: U2 returns" went up earlier today. The following sites updated: